Friday, February 4, 2011

The Online Reporter Quote of the Week... Stat of the Week...

“With all this digital technology there’s still consumer confusion [and] if the consumer is confused, none of it’s going to work,” 

- NBTV Studios producer Nick Buzzell.


Stat of the Week... 

Manufacturers sold 33.3 million Android devices in Q4 — up sevenfold from Q4 2009 — beating out Symbian’s 31 million sales.

LIES, DAMN LIES AND STATISTICS - A Look at the Mobile Market


 
 - Android Gains, Nokia & RIM Dip, Apple Stands Resolute
 
It’s been a big week for mobile research with worldwide and US-specific stats coming out of the woodwork. The big news of the day has been Android and its expected dominance on a global scale. Despite gains for many of the major players in terms of units shipped, Google’s operating system is wrestling away market share and limelight from those who previously controlled what the market looked at. 

While all the world’s a stage, the US is garnering attention because of the dead heat of three platforms going on in the country. Innovation for apps is key to the market, so it’ll be very telling when one of these systems emerges as a victor. Thanks to the iPhone soon moving to more networks than just AT&T, carrier choice will begin playing less of a role in terms of smartphone choice by consumers and investment from developers.

 Android Goes for Global Gold

Research firm Canalys has reported that Android has overtaken long-reigning leader Nokia’s Symbian as the top smartphone platform globally in the fourth quarter of 2010.

Manufacturers sold 33.3 million Android devices in Q4 — up sevenfold from Q4 2009 — beating out Symbian’s 31 million sales. Android accounts for 32.9% of smartphones shipped while Nokia only accounted for 30.6% — this is a dramatic fall from its 44.4% market share a year ago. Android saw a 615% growth year-over-year, compared to Nokia’s 30% growth.

The Finnish company still led as the largest hardware maker with 28% of the market, but it can no longer assume it has the most popular software.

Android’s success appears to come largely from the sheer number of manufacturers developing Android devices, flooding the market not only with a wide range of functionality but also a wide range of pricing and specialization. While many makers were completely new to Android, others have been involved significantly since 2009. Acer, HTC, LG and Samsung saw gains in Android device sales ranging from 371% (HTC) to 4,127% (LG).

Motorola and Sony Ericsson are considered to have secured their places and saved themselves from large losses by dropping other platforms, like Windows Phone 7/Mobile and Symbian, in favor of Android and supporting high-end devices.

For other companies:
 - Despite almost doubling its shipments compared to Q4 2009, Apple’s market share dipped slightly to 16%.
  - Verizon’s iPhone launch means that the carrier will no longer devote all its attention to Android and this could cause a shift in the US market and marketing. Google may have to look at AT&T to make up for this loss of focus.
  - BlackBerry OS dropped from 20% to 14.4%.
  - RIM secured the top spot in the US for device shipments by individual phone designers.
 - Microsoft, despite Windows Phone 7’s launch, dropped to 3.1%.
 - Nokia N8 sales reportedly reached around 4 million units in the fourth quarter.
 - Nokia is still the largest cellphone manufacturer for all types, but its loss of the top spot to Android is the end of an era for Symbian.

In general, Smartphone sales continue to rise at a lightning quick pace. In the fourth quarter there were 101 million smartphone units shipped out, an 89% growth compared to Q4 2009.

The Top 5 Shifts

While Apple remains one of the top five mobile phone vendors globally, it has conceded the number 4 spot so China’s ZTE, according to the latest report from IDC.
The report said that, despite a record quarter for phone shipments, Apple dipped into fifth place. Apple shipped 16.2 million units, an increase of 2.1 million units from the prior quarter — up significantly from Q4 2009’s 8.7 million units.

Reaching the top five for the very first time, ZTE shipped 16.8 million units for the quarter, reaching 4.2% of the market. Lately ZTE has strengthened its smartphone portfolio, launching the Android Blade and Racer phones.
IDC did note that despite ZTE’s surge, it could lose its fourth place spot or even drop out of the top five as each quarter can be affected by big announcements or smartphone shifts.

“Change-up among the number four and five vendors could be a regular occurrence this year,” said Ramon Llamas, senior research analyst with IDC’s mobile devices technology and trends team. “Motorola, Research In Motion, and Sony Ericsson — all vendors with a tight focus on the fast-growing smartphone market who had ranked among the top five worldwide vendors during 2010 — are well within striking distance to move back into the top five list.”

The report also said:
 - Overall, the global mobile phone market rose 17.9% compared to the end of 2009, shipping 401.4 million units versus the year-ago quarter’s 340.5 million units.
 - 2010 saw a total of 1.39 billion units shipped, an 18.5% increase over 2009’s 1.17 billion.
“Feature phone users looking to do more with their devices will flock to smartphones in the years to come,” said Kevin Restivo, a senior IDC research analyst.

 With Tablets, Smartphones Android to Beat iOS for Mobile Data Traffic

When it comes to mobile data consumption, the iPhone’s crown may be getting too heavy.

This year, Android is expected to surpass iOS’ share thanks to new tablets and smartphones reaching the market in the coming months.

According to a Cisco forecast for 2010 to 2015, the iPhone’s data levels were four times greater than any other smartphone at the beginning of 2010. However, by the end of 2010 this data consumption was only 1.75 times greater than that of Android smartphones.
Android is projected to overtake iOS consumption as tablets become more popular. Cisco said that tablets generate five times more traffic than smartphones and it believes that Google’s OS will dominate the tablet market.
“In 2010, 3 million tablets were connected to the mobile network [and] mobile data traffic per tablet was 405MB per month, compared to 79MB per month per smartphone,” said Cisco.

Cisco forecasts that the data consumed by tablets alone in 2015 will reach 248 petabytes per month — the entire global mobile network traffic per month in 2010 was only 242 petabytes.

US Is a Tight Race

The smartphone race is in full swing and it’s a virtual three-way tie for the lead in US market share among Apple’s iOS, Google’s Android and RIM’s BlackBerry OS. Android has been picking up steam while Apple has kept stable and RIM declined, giving each roughly a 28% share of the market as of December, according to new data from Nielsen.

These numbers cover all smartphone owners. If looking back to new purchases within the last six months, Android’s momentum is undeniable. Devices with Google’s mobile operating system account for 43% of recent purchases, beating out Apple’s 26% and RIM’s 20%.

According to Nielsen, roughly 31% of mobile users in the US own a smartphone. Breaking it down by ethnicity in the US, Nielsen found for mobile users:
 - 45% of Hispanics and Asian/Pacific Islanders use smartphones.
 - 56% of Hispanics and 60% of Asian/Pacific Islanders that purchased a phone in the last six months bought a smart phone. The iPhone is the top device among these groups.
 - 33% of African Americans use smartphones.
 - 44% of African Americans that purchased a phone in the last six months bought a smartphone. RIM devices were king among this group.
 - 27% of whites use smartphones.
 - 42% of whites that purchased a phone in the last six months bought a smartphone. Apple’s iPhone also reigned with this group.

Nielsen previously predicted smartphone penetration will surpass 50% of mobile users by the end of 2011, but may end up revising this number. At the end of 2010, smartphone penetration was at 31% of mobile users, compared to 20% at the end of 2009.

The Online Reporter Editor’s note: The Canalys report numbers included a footnote saying that numbers counted for Google’s operating system “relate to Android, as well as the OMS and Tapas platform variants.” There is some concern over this issue as OMS generally considered the basis of China Mobile’s OPhone platform and Tapas is modified to support Chinese services that are not connected with Google or its platform. Both were originally constructed as variants of Android, but have evolved. OMS is generally considered to be more sympathetic to Windows systems, is incompatible with many features of and apps for Android, and China Mobile has its own SDK for OMS with at least 500 apps. While its roots are in Android, Tapas was developed as an Android competitor by the former president of Google China and has announced deals with Sharp, Haier and Tianyu to license Tapas OS for phones aimed at China.


Global Smartphone Market

Q4 2010 Shipments (millions)
% Share
Q4 2009 Shipments (millions)
% Share
Growth
Total
101.2
100%
53.7
100%
88.6%
Google
33.3
32.9%
4.7
8.7%
615.1%
Nokia
31
30.6%
23.9
44.4%
30%
Apple
16.2
16%
8.7
16.3%
85.9%
RIM
14.6
14.4%
10.7
20%
36%
Microsoft
3.1
3.1%
3.9
7.3%
-20.3%
Others
3
2.9%
1.8
3.4%
64.8%
Source: Canalys
To see 4 free editions of The Online Reporter, the weekly source for competitive intelligence about digital content, online entertainment services, mobile media and wireless networks, visit www.onlinereporter.com/trial_copies.php  

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Spain’s Anti-P2P Law Rises from the Grave


Spain’s legal rollercoaster continues. 

Spain previously proposed a piece of legislation that aimed to shut down file-sharing sites and make it easier to penalize caught pirates. At the end of 2010, the Spanish House of Representatives decided to reject the proposal due to the public opposition.

The law has now resurfaced with a few caveats, but the public still appears inflamed.
Spanish courts traditionally operate on the basis that P2P Web sites operate legally and that the only punishable offense comes when their operators are making monetary gains off the distribution of copyrighted works — monetary gains here have also needed to be significant to see site owners face any sort of harsh penalty.

The new legislation goes against this precedence by moving around it. The law says that sites offering infringing links to copyright works can be taken offline without a judicial order, and would likely lead to the shutdown of all major file-sharing sites in the country.
The revision introduced more judicial control by requiring a court to sign off on requests to hand over the personal details on Web site owners, but the legislation does not require a judge to be part of the decision about whether or not a site is infringing on copyrights.

So far, the new legislation has received almost entirely negative press in Spain. Even the president of the Academy of Cinema, Álex de la Iglesia, critiqued it as “a law that does not suit anybody.”

This legislation, part of the Sustainable Economy Law, was drafted by Minister of Culture Ángeles González-Sinde with help the US government. The extent of the role the US played in the provision’s creation is unclear, but this fact alone has faced a tough criticism and calls for the amendment to once again be removed from any legislation.


To see 4 free editions of The Online Reporter, the weekly source for competitive intelligence about digital content, online entertainment services, mobile media and wireless networks, visit www.onlinereporter.com/trial_copies.php  


EMI, MP3tunes Court Case Approaches


MP3tunes head Michael Robertson has been writing about the January 28 court date for his company’s legal battle with record label EMI. According to Robertson, oral arguments will be presented on the matters at hand, with the judge questioning both sides but not issuing a decision for some time. 

Robertson hopes the questions will give a sense of how the judge is leaning and plans to share what is asked on both sides.

Robertson also had some barbed words for Sony Music’s Thomas Hesse, who criticized “shady” digital locker services at the recent MIDEM conference.

“I’m not sure legal criticism from the company who tried to secretly install software to control your PC triggering a class action lawsuit (rootkit), been involved in multiple anti-trust actions include price fixing, and who’s artist accounting is under constant criticism and lawsuits has much credibility,” wrote Robertson.

Robertson’s comments can be found at http://www.michaelrobertson.com/, though we’ll stick with coverage of what’s submitted to the court and of its eventual outcome, expected in the summer months.



To see 4 free editions of The Online Reporter, the weekly source for competitive intelligence about digital content, online entertainment services, mobile media and wireless networks, visit www.onlinereporter.com/trial_copies.php  

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Android Faces Potentially Major Copyright Problems

There are new allegations that Google has directly copied between 37 and 44 Java source files in Android, and it’s tough to tell if this will be a dismissible event or a major headache for Google.

Directly copying these files is a major accusation, especially as Oracle is currently suing Google for patent and copyright infringement related to Java.

Initial reaction to the news has been that this isn’t a major issue. So far, most are saying that all the files in question appear to be test files that aren’t important to Android overall and they likely aren’t shipping on Android units, so the racket is over nothing. In a technical sense, these observations and objections are spot-on.

The problem here is that the legal sense and the technical sense are incompatible here.

From a legal perspective, these files create an increased liability for Google. Current copyright laws in the US do not govern or make exceptions for how source code trees work, how pasted script relates to other licenses or if it matters whether such files make their way to the final consumer product.

Legally, the most relevant question appears to be: “Did Oracle approve of and authorize the copying and potential distribution of these files?”

In short, the answer is no. Google appears to be in the wrong because it replaced a public license with a different open source license when it potentially distributed these files. The change in license means that the Android shipped to handsets will be considered an unauthorized copy of these Java files. 

This matters because Oracle wants to receive a per-handset royalty check on every Android device shipped, and this code-copying gives them some strong leverage. ‘Those files we took aren’t important’ doesn’t sound like a great legal defense, and issues like this mounting up could very well incline a judge to feel that Google is in the wrong. 

To see 4 free editions of The Online Reporter, the weekly source for competitive intelligence about digital content, online entertainment services, mobile media and wireless networks, visit www.onlinereporter.com/trial_copies.php  
 

Obama Pushes High-Speed Wireless

In his recent State of the Union address, President Barack Obama called for an expansion of high-speed wireless services to meet the needs of US consumers and businesses.

“Within the next five years, we will make it possible for businesses to deploy the next generation of high-speed wireless coverage to 98% of all Americans,” said President Obama. “This isn’t just about a faster Internet and fewer dropped calls. It’s about connecting every part of America to the digital age.”

Obama only gave a slight nod toward how difficult universal connectivity may become since the potential for demand is limitless while spectrum available for these services is quite limited.

The Obama administration has previously endorsed making 500 MHz of wireless spectrum available over the next decade to meet the growing demand for broadband services for both mobile devices and homes.

The Federal Communications Commission hopes to repurpose 120 MHz of spectrum through incentive auctions where TV broadcasters voluntarily give up spectrum in exchange for a portion of the proceeds.
The broadcast TV industry has raised some concerns over these sales, the most recent of which is that the spectrum the industry gave up nearly two years ago has yet to be fully utilized. Its inclusion in the speech, however, may mean the industry’s concerns will play second fiddle.

Wi-Fi’s Numbers Keep Growing


At the 2010 TelcoTV conference, the thought of Wi-Fi being the “true 4G standard” popped up briefly on a panel discussion, and at the 2010 TV 3.0 conference, Wi-Fi was called the “default” home networking standard at a few booths. 

Both of these names have popped up again recently at CES and elsewhere, and they bear a little fleshing out.

These ideas stem from Wi-FiMedialink - Wireless G USB Adapter - 802.11g - 54Mbps - 2.4ghz - Windows 2000 / XP / Vista 32-Bit / Vista 64-Bit / Windows 7 Compatible being almost everywhere, from homes and coffee shops to airports and auto repair shops. Consumers have gotten used to Wi-Fi being everywhere, so now they demand fast speeds without a wired connection, not really caring where the service comes from. Wi-Fi is usually piggybacking on a wired network connection, and with the speeds being demanded, there are many saying that fiber is the only way to keep up.


Couple this thought with the overburdened 3G networks most are still on with their mobile devices, and Wi-Fi looks to be the key to bridging the gap between mobile and fiber, removing the cumbersome amount of users on a mobile network while also diminishing the costs of fiber, which is generally thought of as too expensive to roll out to every location that wants it.


With all of these thoughts floating around, it’s worth taking a quick look at new applications of Wi-Fi that are cropping up:

 - BT has developed an iPad app that allows broadband subscribers to access more than two million hotspots in the UK.

 - Boingo Wireless, which operates around 200,000 global hotspots, largely in airports, is looking into a stock market listing.

 - BSkyB is planning to purchase The Cloud, which operates 22,000 hotspots in Europe.

 - Airlines like Delta, United and Virgin are offering Wi-Fi on their longer flights.

 - Orange France, Eutelsat, Alsthom, SNCF and Capgemini are deploying on-board Wi-Fi in the TGV (France’s high-speed rail service).


 - Telenet has decided not to participate in Belgian spectrum auctions in order to focus on cable and Wi-Fi offerings.


The latest news for how standard Wi-Fi has become is the new premium offering from O2 UK. Calling it “O2 Wi-Fi,” the company will give hotspot access to people for free, no matter what mobile or broadband provider they use. O2 said it’ll at least double the number of hotspots offered by BT Openzone and The Cloud combined by the beginning of 2013.


Its initial launch will cover the existing 450 hotspots offered under Cloud branding. All hotspots will be premium public offerings, removing the limited bandwidth associated with residential connections.


Wi-Fi is not only a big part of the future — it’s a bridge to get there faster.

To see 4 free editions of The Online Reporter, the weekly source for competitive intelligence about digital content, online entertainment services, mobile media and wireless networks, visit www.onlinereporter.com/trial_copies.php